Blood and Sand and Booze

This cocktail is called the Blood and Sand, after the 1922 film of that name starring Rudolph Valentino. He portrays an impoverished lad who becomes one of the greatest matadors in Spain. (The ceramic bull and matador in the pic, by the way, were a gift from my paternal grandmother, who made and sold ceramics for a living.) The Blood and Sand is a somewhat bewildering cocktail that involves 3/4 oz. Scotch whisky, 3/4 oz. cherry liqueur (preferably Heering), 3/4 oz. sweet vermouth, and 3/4 oz. orange juice. It’s tasty but has a “just miss” character because three of its four ingredients are sweet. Lemon or lime juice would offset the sweetness but neither really works in the cocktail, so you either have to live with it or—and this is ingenious—add citric acid so that the orange juice retains its flavor but becomes more tart. Yet another example of better living through chemistry. To make a Blood and Sand (sans citric acid), pour the four ingredients into a mixing tin filled with ic...